New England Lobster Roll

The summer my cousin opened her seafood shack in Maine, she put me on lobster roll duty for opening weekend. I was terrified of ruining $200 worth of lobster, but she taught me that the secret isn't some fancy technique. It's knowing when to stop adding things and let that sweet, briny meat speak for itself.

Last Fourth of July, I made these for a backyard cookout while my dad watched from the porch, nursing his skepticism about buying lobster from the grocery store. One bite in and he was asking if I could make them every weekend. That's when I knew this recipe wasn't just for vacation anymore.

Ingredients

• 500 g cooked lobster meat: I've learned that mixing claw, knuckle, and tail gives you the best range of textures and sweetness
• 2–3 tbsp mayonnaise or 60 g melted butter: This is where you decide your roll's personality, cool and creamy or warm and luxurious
• 1 tbsp lemon juice: Freshly squeezed is nonnegotiable here, bottled lemon just tastes flat and harsh against the lobster
• 1 tbsp finely chopped celery: This adds the tiniest crunch without overwhelming the delicate meat
• 1 tbsp finely chopped chives or scallions: They bring this gentle onion flavor that somehow makes everything taste brighter
• Salt and freshly ground black pepper: Lobster needs salt, but be careful, it's easy to go too far and lose that sweet ocean flavor
• 4 split-top brioche rolls: The brioche is crucial, regular buns get soggy too fast and don't have that rich buttery sweetness
• 2 tbsp unsalted butter softened: For toasting the rolls, and yes, you need this much to get that gorgeous golden exterior
• Lemon wedges and chopped fresh parsley: These aren't just garnish, that squeeze of fresh lemon right before eating is transformative

Instructions

Mix the lobster gently:

Combine the lobster meat with your chosen dressing, lemon juice, celery, and chives in a medium bowl, folding everything together like you're handling something precious because you basically are

Get your rolls golden and crispy:

Heat your skillet over medium heat, butter those brioche rolls like you mean it, and toast them until they're a deep golden brown on both sides, about 1–2 minutes per side

Load them up generously:

Open each toasted roll and pack in the lobster mixture until it's practically spilling over the sides

Add the finishing touches:

Sprinkle with fresh parsley and serve immediately with lemon wedges on the side so everyone can add that final bright squeeze themselves

Save Pin

These rolls have become my go-to for summer entertaining, mostly because they make people feel special without requiring me to spend hours over a hot stove while everyone else is having fun. There's something about handing someone a lobster roll that makes their eyes light up.

The Great Debate: Maine vs Connecticut Style

After years of making both versions, I've realized that the mayonnaise style is perfect for hot days when you want something refreshing, while the warm butter version feels like a hug on a chilly evening. Both are valid, both are delicious, and nobody needs to pick a permanent team.

Buying the Right Lobster

I used to think I needed live lobsters to make decent rolls, but high-quality cooked lobster meat from a reliable fish counter works beautifully. Just avoid the frozen stuff if you can, the texture never quite recovers, and you deserve better than rubbery lobster in your roll.

What to Serve Alongside

The beauty of a lobster roll is that it's substantial enough to be the star of the show, so I keep sides simple and let the seafood shine. A little crunch and something tangy is all you really need.

• Kettle-cooked potato chips are practically mandatory, that extra crunch is perfect
• A simple coleslaw with a light vinaigrette won't compete with the lobster
• Corn on the barbie, maybe with some herbs and a squeeze of lime

Save Pin

Whether you're celebrating summer or just need a reminder that good food doesn't have to be complicated, these rolls deliver something special every single time. Life's too short for mediocre seafood.

Recipe Help & FAQs

→ What's the difference between New England and Connecticut style lobster rolls?

New England style features lobster meat dressed with mayonnaise, while Connecticut style uses warm melted butter instead. Both versions include fresh lemon juice, but the butter variation creates a richer, warmer flavor profile.

→ Can I use frozen lobster meat for this preparation?

Yes, frozen lobster meat works well if thawed properly and drained thoroughly. Pat the meat dry before mixing to prevent excess water from diluting the dressing. Fresh lobster will have slightly better texture and sweetness.

→ What type of rolls work best for this dish?

Split-top brioche rolls or New England-style hot dog buns are traditional choices. The brioche adds richness and holds up well to butter toasting. Look for rolls with a soft interior and sturdy exterior that can stand up to the generous lobster filling.

→ How should I store leftover lobster mixture?

Store the dressed lobster mixture in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to one day. The texture may become slightly softer as the dressing absorbs into the meat. For best results, assemble the rolls just before serving rather than storing them fully assembled.

→ What sides complement this main dish?

Kettle-cooked potato chips provide the classic crunch contrast, while creamy coleslaw offers a refreshing acidic balance. Other excellent pairings include pickles, corn on the cob, or a light green salad with vinaigrette to cut through the rich butter and mayonnaise.

→ Can I make this lighter without sacrificing flavor?

Substitute Greek yogurt for mayonnaise to reduce calories while maintaining creaminess. You can also decrease the amount of dressing slightly—the sweet lobster flavor shines through with minimal additions. Focus on high-quality fresh lobster and you won't need heavy dressing.